Choosing The Right Makeup If You Have Sensitive Eyes

People across the world suffer from various allergies and irritations every single day due to their overuse of harmful cosmetics. Most cosmetic products contain toxic chemicals including nanoparticles, parabens, fragrances, artificial colorings and bismuth oxychloride. While these products may not cause huge irritation or other problems on first use, they can build up and become problematic over time.

Eye irritation is one of the most annoying things that can happen to a person. Dry and sensitive eyes can be painful and tiring, and your vision can even be affected after some time. Our eyes are one of the most sensitive parts of our bodies. Even if you don’t suffer any allergies and aren’t generally sensitive to cosmetics, you may suffer a reaction to certain eyeliners and eye makeups.

In this case, you probably need to make use of a hypoallergenic eye makeup.

Best Hypoallergenic Eye Makeup Brands: Comparison Chart​

Featured Product

Best Overall - Hypoallergenic Eye Makeup

2nd Choice

3rd Choice

4th Choice

5th Choice

Top Hypoallergenic Eye Makeup Brands 2017

Lancome Artliner 24H Bold Color Precision Eyeliner
24/7 Waterline Eye Pencil
Defining Mascara
Trio Eye Palette – 3 In 1
Jane Iredale ‘In The Blink Of A Smoky Eye’ Kit

Product Name

Artliner 24H Bold Color Precision Eyeliner

24/7 Waterline Eye Pencil

Defining Mascara

Ever-Matte Poreless Priming Perfector™

Shine Control Primer




Laura Mercier



Chief Ingredients


Hydrogenated Polyisobutene, Isododecane, Synthetic Wax and Polymethylsilsesquioxane

Water (Aqua), Cera Alba, Stearic Acid, Copernicia Cerifera Wax and Glyceryl Stearate

Caprylic/Capric Triglycerides, Dehydroacetic Acid, Iron Oxide, Titanium Dioxide and Mica

Mica, Boron Nitride, Dimethicone and Pinus Strobus Bark Extract

Eye Finish

Unique wet-vinyl finish

Waterproof color in never-before-seen shades

Adds life to the lashes without flaking, smudging or clumping

Medium Matte BrownLight Matte BrownLight Matte Creme (beige)

Holds eight shades to create favorite smoky eye

Lasting Period

Full 24 hours

All day

All day

Long lasting

Long-lasting eye color


0.05 oz.

0.05 oz.

0.23 fl. oz.

0.19 oz.


Our Rating

Buy Now

What is Hypoallergenic Makeup?

Hypoallergenic makeup is basically makeup which is designed for people with allergies or sensitivities to certain chemicals. It is usually specially formulated, and is therefore safer to use and generally less harmful than standard cosmetics.

People throughout the world use hypoallergenic cosmetics every single day to manage their allergies and to reduce eye irritation. Most hypoallergenic makeup for sensitive eyes will be completely natural, and many are even organic. However, some products (generally the cheaper ones) will be formulated using synthetic ingredients. When this is the case, known irritants such as phenoxyethanol, quaternium, methylisothiazolinone, or imidazolidinyl are avoided and safer chemicals are generally used.

If you have trouble with allergies or irritation using normal makeup, then it could be time for you to try a hypoallergenic eye makeup.

What are the Signs That You Need to Choose Makeup for Sensitive Eyes?

If you have any sort of sensitivity or discomfort when using normal cosmetic products, it could be time to go with a hypoallergenic eye makeup. Doing so should help reduce your discomfort, and will reduce your chances of getting red, puffy eyes during the day. Some of the most obvious signs that you need to choose an eye makeup which is specially formulated for sensitive eyes include:

If You Frequently Suffer From Dry and Irritated Eyes

If you are one of the poor people who suffer from irritated eyes every day, then it could be time for you to trial a few different hypoallergenic eyeliners. Wearing makeup is designed to make you look better and to cover up imperfections. However, it is very hard to hide red and puffy eyes, and therefore there is no point wearing an eyeliner or mascara if your eyes react badly to it.

You are Sensitive to Artificial Fragrances Or Perfumes

This type of sensitivity may manifest itself in the form of light headaches, a runny nose, or dry and sensitive eyes. A huge percentage of people are vulnerable to reactions from artificial fragrances, and their lives are affected every single day.

Although you may not realize it, the fragrances and other chemicals in your eye makeup may be causing reactions in your body. Not only can they make your eyes dry out, but they can also give you headaches and can affect your respiratory system. If you are suffering from any of these symptoms, then it could be time for you to choose a new hypoallergenic makeup.

Choosing a Hypoallergenic Eye Makeup

There are literally hundreds of different makeup products on the market which are specially formulated for sensitive eyes. Eyeshadows for sensitive eyelids are everywhere, but do they actually work? You may be a little skeptical, and with good reason: many products which are marketed as hypoallergenic and specially formulated for sensitive skin still contain a wide range of harmful and toxic chemicals.

When you are trying to find a new eye makeup for sensitive eyes, try and look out for the following things:

Look at the ingredients – does it contain any fragrance?

There is absolutely no reason for eye makeups to contain artificial fragrances and perfumes. Unfortunately, many are full of them. They can irritate your eyes, especially if you are sensitive to synthetic chemicals in general. Go for products which don’t contain any artificial fragrances. Use a natural perfume to freshen yourself up: eye makeup is for looks only!

Look at the ingredients again – are there any other irritating ingredients present?

There are literally thousands of cosmetic ingredients out there which can irritate sensitive eyes. Fortunately, there are some very common ones which you can keep your eyes out for. Some of the most frequently encountered irritating chemicals in eye makeup include parabens, bismuth oxychloride, formaldehyde, and even certain red dyes (colors). Avoiding these will go a long way towards reducing eye irritation.

Look at the ingredients one final time:Go for products with few ingredients, and with as many natural and organic ingredients as possible. There is no reason to use makeup which is formulated from hundreds of different chemicals. Generally, products like this are no better than products with just a few ingredients: the only difference is that they are much more likely to irritate your eyes. Mineral based cosmetics with few ingredients can also be good options.

Use Trial and Error

When developing a new cosmetic regime it is important to realize that some form of trial and error is likely to be necessary. You should never go and choose a product off the shelf and decide that it is going to become the basis of your makeup. Even the best hypoallergenic eye makeup can cause irritation in certain people.

Basically, you need to choose a range of different makeups, try each one for a few days at a time, and monitor your skin’s reaction to each one. Use the one which gives the least reaction and the which looks the best.

Our Top 10 Best Makeup for Sensitive Eyes

Choosing the right eye makeup can be extremely difficult. We understand how frustrating and time consuming it can be, especially if you have no background in the cosmetic or beauty industry.

Fortunately for you, we have compiled a list of our favorite eye cosmetics for people with sensitive skin. We hope that this will get you started on your search for the right products for you, and who knows, one of the following products may be exactly what you need!

Our Top 10 Best Makeups for Sensitive Eyes Include:

1. Lancome Artliner 24H Bold Color Precision Eyeliner

Lancome Artliner 24H Bold Color Precision Eyeliner

Lancome is an old French cosmetic brand which is extremely well known for its scientific approach to cosmetic formulation. Their liquid eyeliner for sensitive eyes is especially effective, and will leave you feeling healthy and invigorated.

The best eyeliner for sensitive eyelids is one which doesn’t cause you to tear up if you get a tiny bit in them. The Lancome Artliner 24H Bold Color Precision Eyeliner works great. It is completely free of irritating chemicals such as sulfates and phthalates, and therefore it will hardly ever lead to irritation or redness of the eyes. Again, make sure that you use a trial and error approach when you are choosing new cosmetic products.

In our opinion, this is probably the best liquid eyeliner for sensitive eyes. Not only is it easy on your skin and eyes, but it also looks incredible! It is full of pigments which will allow you to achieve the perfect look for your night out, and it is resistant to moisture, which means that watering eyes won’t affect it too much.

2. Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eye Pencil

24/7 Waterline Eye Pencil

This is, in the opinion of many beauty writers and professionals, the best eyeliner for sensitive eyes. It is designed to leave your eyes looking incredibly beautiful, and if specially formulated for people with sensitive eyes and eyelids.

If you have sensitive eyes, then you know how hard it can be to apply eyeliner. One mistake and your eyes will begin watering, causing the makeup you have already put on to run and become a mess, meaning that you have to start all over again.

Well, the good news is that with the Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eye Pencil, you will never have to worry about problems like this again! It is formulated without parabens, which makes it a great hypoallergenic eyeliner for sensitive eyes. Once applied, it will set into place, meaning that it shouldn’t budge even if your sensitive eyes do begin to water or react to a chemical.

This eye pencil comes in a range of colors including the standard black and a few colorful shades. It is designed to be super simple to apply, and therefore is great for those of us with little time to worry about difficult cosmetics.

3. RMS Beauty Defining Mascara

 RMS Beauty Defining Mascara

If you are searching for a great, hypoallergenic mascara, then you are probably having trouble finding a decent sounding product. Mascara for sensitive eyes is unfortunately quite rare, and even when products claim to be designed for use by people with sensitive eyes, they are often still irritating.

The RMS Beauty Defining Mascara is great, but it has one downside: it takes a long time to dry compared to other mascaras on the market. However, this generally leads to much better results, and you should find that it gives you long, elegant lashes.

Specially formulated with no alpha-hydroxy acids or other harmful products, this mascara is absolutely perfect for people who suffer from sensitive and easily irritable eyes. It won a prestigious best of beauty award in 2014, and is absolutely worth the slightly higher price tag that is attached to it.

I would personally recommend this mascara – as long you can hold still for 30 seconds while it dries that is!

4. Trio Eye Palette – 3 In 1!

Trio Eye Palette – 3 In 1

If you are trying to buy an eyeliner for sensitive eyelids, why not get an eyeshadow and eyebrow kit at the same time? The Trio Eye Palette is the perfect choice. It includes a range of different colors in an easy to use format.

This easy to use travel kit comes complete with a mirror, a dual end applicator, and instructions on how to use it to shape your eyebrows, to highlight certain parts of your eyes, or as a simple eyeliner. It is designed to remain in great condition for a long time, which means that you won’t have to worry about reapplication and touch-ups throughout the day or night.

With no parabens, binders, fillers, or artificial fragrances, this is undoubtedly a great product for people who are unfortunate enough to suffer from sensitive skin or eyes. It shouldn’t cause any reaction or irritation, and will therefore make your life much easier.

If you aren’t sure about this product, then give it a try! You won’t be disappointed. It comes at a very affordable price, and should be within the budget of most people.

5. Jane Iredale ‘In The Blink Of A Smoky Eye’ Kit

Jane Iredale ‘In The Blink Of A Smoky Eye’ Kit

This is undoubtedly one of the great cosmetic products out there if you are looking for an eyeshadow for sensitive eyes. If you, like many people, tend to stay away from eyeshadow altogether due to your sensitive eyes, then this product is for you!

It is specially formulated for people with sensitive eyes and eyelids, and will not cause any kind of reaction or irritation (in most people, but there will always be exceptions to the rule). Mineral based cosmetics, such as those based on oxides such as zinc oxide and titanium oxide, are generally among the best for sensitive eyes.

This colorful palette of eyeshadows is formulated without toxic ingredients. It contains an almost natural base, and the colors come from various mineral compounds. If you enjoy wearing different color eyeshadows according to the event or situation, then this product is something you must consider!

If you are like many other people who have sensitive eyes, and don’t often use things like eyeshadow, then you may not really know the best way to apply it. Fear not! With this kit from Jane Iredale comes complete with step-by-step instructions on how to apply eyeshadows for the best effect.

6. Cleure Eyeliner Powderliner Pencil

Trying to find the best hypoallergenic eyeliner on the market can be extremely difficult, if not impossible. However, the good news is that there are some decent products out there (thankfully!). One of these is the Cleure Eyeliner Powderline Pencil.

Free of harmful chemicals and irritants, this is undoubtedly one of the best eyeliners for sensitive eyes. If you aren’t sure where to start looking for a new eyeliner which doesn’t irritate and damage your eyes, then this is a great place to start! The special mineral formulation of this eyeliner keeps it free of toxic parabens, artificial fragrances, gluten, salicylate, and any other chemicals which can be irritating to sensitive eyes.

It is also the perfect choice for the environmentally conscious consumer. It is completely cruelty free, and contains no animal derived products – something that many cosmetics can’t claim.

People generally love this eyeliner, and it comes with extremely high ratings from beauty industry professionals. Some features which are highly favored include great colors, an easy to apply texture which isn’t too hard in cold weather or too soft in warm weather, and a formulation which is able to stay put throughout even the most difficult day.

7. bareMinerals ‘Precious Pearls’ Eyecolor Trio

bareMinerals ‘Precious Pearls’ Eyecolor Trio

This is possible one of the best products on the market for people who wear contact lenses. If you are a contact wearer then you will understand just how painful and irritating regular eyeshadows can be. They are generally powdery, and can fall into the eyes, irritating and causing redness and excessive watering.

Luckily for you, the bareMinerals ‘Precious Pearls’ Eyecolor Trio is specially formulated for people like you. It is dermatologist and ophthalmologist tested, and is absolutely safe to use with contact lenses.

Not only is this a great product which is safe for people with even the most sensitive eyes, but it also looks amazing – in our opinion, it rivals even the best non-hypoallergenic eyeshadows. With three shades to choose from – cultured pearl, blissful pearl, and magnificent – this eyeshadow kit really does have it all!

8. Burberry Effortless Blendable Kohl – Multi-Use Crayon

Burberry Effortless Blendable Kohl – Multi-Use Crayon

If you are looking for a versatile product which is perfect for people with even the most sensitive eyes, then go no further than this wonderful crayon by Burberry. It has been thoroughly tested on both sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, and passed both with flying colors.

It contains no parabens, sulfates, or phthalates, and therefore has little chance of causing painful irritation. The crayon is very versatile, and can be used as an eyeliner, a kohl, or even as an eyeshadow – your imagination is the only constraint!

9. CoverGirl Lashblast Waterproof Mascara The Super Sizer

CoverGirl Lashblast Waterproof Mascara The Super Sizer

Although many people would argue otherwise, you don’t need to use false lashes to achieve a full, beautiful look. A high-quality mascara will have exactly the same effect, without causing the irritation and pain that false lashes can.

This great mascara from CoverGirl is perfect for people with sensitive eyes. It is specially formulated to be safe for use with contacts, and shouldn’t cause irritation or eye redness, especially if applied right.

Not only is it safe for sensitive eyes, but this product is also touted to give you wonderfully long and voluminous eyelashes without having to use false lashes. Try it today and find out how good it really is!

10. Bobbi Brown Eye Makeup Remover

Bobbi Brown Eye Makeup Remover

Taking your makeup off at night is absolutely essential. Doing so reduces the chance of irritation arising during the night or the next day, and will help keep your skin healthy and clean for years to come. In our educated opinion, the Bobbi Brown Eye Makeup Remover is one of the best removal products on the market.

It is water-based, which means that it is safe to use on oily and pimple prone skin. It won’t cause acne outbreaks, and won’t contribute to irritation and allergies like other products can.

It is formulated around two of the best natural cosmetic ingredients on the market: aloe vera and rosewater extract. The aloe vera works to reduce irritation and smooth your skin. It is full or anti-inflammatories, anti-irritants, and is extremely hydrating, leaving your eyes and the areas surrounding your eyes clean and refreshed after you take your makeup off.

Rosewater extract is also a great ingredient for sensitive skin. It seems to smooth and refresh sensitive skin, and works especially well if your eyes are a little bit irritated or dry following a day of wearing makeup.

Although the Bobbi Brown Eye Makeup Remover is slightly on the expensive side, it’s value can’t be underestimated if you regularly suffer from sensitive, dry, or irritated eyes.

Some Sensitive Eye Makeup Tips: Get The Most Out Of Your Makeup!

Choosing and applying makeup is an art which must be learned and practiced regularly. However, it can be hard to do this is you have sensitive or allergy prone eyes, as makeup application can be painful and annoying. The following tips will help you choose the best makeups for your sensitive eyes, and should make your life a lot easier in the future!

  • Always go for products with minimal ingredients. If you can’t pronounce the name of an ingredient, then it probably isn’t hypoallergenic or safe to use!
  • If you continually suffer from extreme sensitivity and inflammation – even when not using large amounts of makeup – then you may need to use something like hydrocortisone cream to keep your eyes healthy.
  • Remember, natural is always better. Organic is another big plus. Our bodies weren’t made to cope with large amounts of toxic chemicals: why subject them to torture in the form of toxic cosmetics when there are plenty of natural alternatives on the market.
  • Lastly, remember that no single product will work the same for everyone. You will probably need to try a few products before you find one which is perfect for your needs.

It doesn’t matter how sensitive your eyes are or how much they react to certain cosmetics, there are products out there which you will find are safe to use. Good luck, and hopefully this article has set you on the track to finding the right makeup products!​